MEMBER PROFILE:

Michael Chisolm

Member Photo

Location

Manhattan

Most Memorable Meal

Les Freres Troisgros

Favorite Food City or Place

West and East Village

Favorite Cookbook

Mastering the Art of French Cooking, Vol. 1

Recommended Restaurants

  1. Hearth

    for: Everything

  2. Esca

    for: Fish, fish, fish done perfectly.

  3. Per Se

    for: Rabbit but really everything is quite magnificent except, perhaps the lobster poached in butter. The wine pairing is both perceptive and enlightening.

Ratings and Reviews

5 Ninth

Rating

New York, NY

Food

American, Fusion, Southeast Asian

Service

05/14/09

The food is quite impressive, but the service is inept and stupid.

Babbo

Rating

New York, NY

Food

Italian

Service

09/23/08

Despite the noise and the college fraternity atmosphere, this is stunning food.

Blue Hill

Rating

New York, NY

Food

American

Service

09/23/08

This is excellent cooking, but I don't find it that interesting. However, that doesn't preclude the fact that I go there fairly often.

Chanterelle (CLOSED)

Rating

New York, NY

Food

French

Service

09/23/08

Chanterelle is the height of elegance in terms of cuisine, service and ambiance. I've never had a meal there that I haven't loved without reservation. It should be noted that this has been the case for more than twenty years. Chanterelle is the soul of consistency and elegance.

Daniel

Rating

New York, NY

Food

French

Service

09/23/08

I used to say that this is the best restaurant at which I've dined in the United States. That's no longer the case, but it's still quite fine.

Degustation

Rating

New York, NY

Food

Spanish, Tapas, French

Service

09/23/08

Brilliant in every way; an astonishing dining experience. I don't quite get the bar thing, but the food compensated for it.

Gotham Bar and Grill

Rating

New York, NY

Food

New American

Service

09/23/08

This is an astonishing dining experinece. The food is stunning, and the service is marvelous. I should go here more often considering that I live near it. The room is brilliant, the service is professional, and the cuisine is brilliant.

Gusto Ristorante e Bar Americano

Rating

New York, NY

Food

Italian

Service

09/23/08

This is really more latter day diso than restaurant. The food is not bad, but between the loud music and general noise level, the dining experience is considerably diminished. During warm weather, one is better off eating on the sidewalk. On one occassion, I told a waiter that the food is too good for the music to this loud.

Hearth

Rating

New York, NY

Food

American, Italian

Service

09/23/08

Hearth is consistent, creative, and a fine dining experience.

iCi

Rating

Brooklyn, NY

Food

New American, French

Service

09/23/08

Ici is the little engine that could. If I lived in Brooklyn, I'd probably eat here several times a week.

Mas (Farmhouse)

Rating

New York, NY

Food

New American, French

Service

09/24/08

I really wish that this were better; their heart is in the right place.

Momofuku Noodle Bar

Rating

New York, NY

Food

Southeast Asian, Chinese, Japanese, Korean

Service

09/24/08

Pork, pork, pork, but quite well done. The bar thing is a bit annoying.

Perry Street

Rating

New York, NY

Food

New American

Service

09/23/08

Not brilliant from someone who has pretentions to brilliance. It's a stunning room, but the food is just not moving.

Hundred Acres

Rating

New York, NY

Food

American

Service

09/23/08

Though the food is quite astonishing, the noise level is at times unbearable.

Savoy (CLOSED)

Rating

New York, NY

Food

American

Service

09/23/08

Lunch, dinner..it doesn't matter; Savoy is right on. Their cassoulet is very special.

Soto

Rating

New York, NY

Food

Japanese, Sushi

Service

08/16/09

The food is pristine, minimal and outstandingly delicious. This is clearly the art of sushi.

Centro Vinoteca

Rating

New York, NY

Food

Italian

Service

09/23/08

This may possibly be the noisest restaurant that in which I've ever dined. The food is quite interesting, but it's probably best eaten alone thus not having to have an unheard conversation with anyone.

Bobo

Rating

New York, NY

Food

European, French

Service

09/23/08

Despite its unfortunate decor, the food is not bad, but not the most interesting or arresting. One tends to think of this restaurant without a sign as slightly pretentious with not much to back up that pretention.

Belcourt

Rating

New York, NY

Food

French, Mediterranean

Service

09/23/08

I have never had a meal at Belcourt that wasn't excellent which was made better by the fact that the price is right. The chef is astonishingly creative. The brunch menu is not egg heavy and quite astonishing.

Kobma Thai

Rating

New York, NY

Food

Japanese

Service

09/23/08

This is not a restaurant to be taken seriously. I rely on this for occassional take out or delivery. One wants to have the eggplant salad with (shudder) tofu. It's quite refreshing and sapid.

Mi Cocina (CLOSED)

Rating

New York, NY

Food

Mexican

Service

09/23/08

I would love to know why this restaurant has been around so long. The food is at best mediocre and the room is ridiculous. Never again.

'sNice

Rating

New York, NY

Food

Vegetarian, Sandwiches

Service

09/24/08

Surprisingly good veggie, especially the soups. However, in my opinion nothing is as good as Indian veggie.

Savory I Want to Eat Here Queue

New York NY

European

New York NY

American, French, Seafood

New York NY

Seafood